If you spend any time going over the result of GSP’s title defense at UFC 167 there is no shortage of dispute among fans. Some believe GSP fairly won three rounds, others say no way, others yet say if GSP won three rounds the two he lost far outweighed those. From there lots of are quick to phone call for policy modifications such as implementing a half-point system or scoring the bout on its whole rather than the sum of its parts.
Truth is no policy modifications are needed. The problem is in the application of the rules, not the policies themselves. The policies contemplate even rounds, they also contemplate proportionately higher scoring for dominant rounds. For whatever reason a culture in judging has established with a reluctance to depart from 10-9 rounds even in the deal with of even or disproportionately one sided rounds.
Nevada’s rules, which were in force for UFC 167, have extremely bit to say about judging criteria. They require as follows:
1. Each judge of a contest or exhibition of mixed martial arts that is being judged shall score the contest or exhibition and figure out the champion with the utilize of the following system:
(a) The better unarmed combatant of a round receives 10 points and his or her opponent proportionately less.
(b) If the round is Camiseta Wolverhampton Wanderers even, each unarmed combatant receives 10 points.
(c) No fraction of points may be given.
(d) Points for every round need to be awarded right away after the end of the period of unarmed battle in the round.
Even rounds are called for. The same judge who awards a extremely close 10-9 round to one combatant is not only complimentary to award a 10-8 in a subsequent a lot more dominant round but is in fact needed to do so. Rounds need to be scored “proportionately“.
If you look to the new jersey rules, which are the foundation behind lots of specify and Provincial commission rules, it is remove that there is much room for deviation from 10-9 rounds. The new jersey policies require as follows:
The 10-Point need to System will be the conventional system of scoring a bout. Under the 10-Point need to scoring System, 10 points need to be awarded to the champion of the round and nine Camiseta Kawasaki Frontale points or less need to be awarded to the loser, except for a rare even round, which is scored (10-10).
Despite stating 10-10 rounds are “rare” the policies go on to set out the following criteria:
1. A round is to be scored Camiseta Rangers FC as a 10-10 round when both contestants appear to be battling evenly and neither contestant shows remove dominance in a round;
2. A round is to be scored as a 10-9 round when a contestant wins by a close margin, landing the higher number of effective legal strikes, grappling and other maneuvers;
3. A round is to be scored as a 10-8 round when a contestant overwhelmingly dominates by striking or grappling in a round.
4. A round is to be scored as a 10-7 round when a contestant absolutely dominates by striking or grappling in a round.
So 10-10 rounds are needed if there is no “clear dominance“. Many rounds in shape this description. Its also remove that 10-8 rounds are not to be utilized as sparingly as they are.
It is hard to describe why judging culture has established with terrific reluctance to depart from 10-9 rounds, but whatever the reason its not the wording of the rules.
Share this:
Twitter
Facebook
Like this:
Like Loading…
Related
Does GSP’s Pre fight Water Spitting Ritual break the Rules?September 8, 2013
Let’s Speculate about GSP’s UFC contract DisputeOctober 18, 2016With 4 comments
GSP apparently Back – will USADA testing Sideline him for 4 Months?February 15, 2017With 1 comment